Isabelle's Liberty Blog

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Watching Sports

 One thing that my family and I do is watch sports. Watching sports brings us together and it's a fun family activity. It has also made me some friends from the past few years. Sports creates conversations by providing common ground, and unified sense of purpose. Some of the players that play sports are great role models for their team or the community. Sports also collect people from different classes and backgrounds. An example would be Nav Bhatia. He is the biggest Toronto Raptors fan and possibly the biggest basketball fan. He has attended every home raptors home game since 1996. Even though he's a fan he is known all across the NBA. He's made thousands of friends and he has even made friends with a lot of Raptors players and staff.  
Read more

IHSS "Liberty"

  Alice Korkin Mr. Roddy IHSS  February 7, 2020 “Liberty”    My definition of Liberty is being free but under the control of the government. Montesquieu’s definition includes the safety of the people. "Tranquillity of mind arising from the opinion each person has of his safety." I agree with this because I also think keeping people safe is important and without rules or laws in a country it will be total chaos. In some countries, laws are way too strict on people. If you are over protectant on people the country won't be a happy place at all. If you just do one small mistake it can wind you down for years of trouble. Liberty is the balance of governmental control. Laws have to be equal for everyone and can not target a single group of people. Laws are supposed to make you feel safe without being confined. An unreasonable law can be one that if you break it, won’t hurt others or yourself. Not only are they for the safety of yourself, but for the safety of others as w...
Read more

"Liberty"

Everest Leo Mr. Roddy IHSS 6 February 2021 "Liberty"     Liberty and freedom are very often used interchangeably in context for free will of the people within a state. As many of us know, liberty and freedom are not interchangeable and within an external political background, this stays the same. I think the way that Montesquieu presents political liberty is very elegant, but like most things in this world is flawed. I agree that there needs to be checks and balances and that total freedom allowing the people to do whatever could result in lots of violence. I agree that laws should not be extensive or ambiguous for the sake of difficult judging and inconsistent legislation. In general, Montesquieu's definition is rather short and efficient, but a place where I do not agree with him is how he would ideally deal with criminals. He says that "the laws should make it as easy as possible for an innocent person to prove his or her innocence." I find this rather unset...
Read more